Home > West Midlands > Chad Valley

Chad Valley West Midlands

Shops

Convenience Stores 764 Auto Repair Shops 592 Clothing Stores 458 Coffee Shops 268 Building Materials Stores 264 Jewellery Shops 224 Furniture Stores 219 Electronics Stores 155 Print Shops 144 DIY Shops 129 Electronics Repair Shops 118 Butcher Shops 111 Petrol Stations 106 Auto Parts Stores 91 Gift Shops 85 Bakeries 74 Boot Stores 73 Tattoo Shops 68 Charity Shops 59 Discount Stores 56 Baby Clothing Stores 52 Book Stores 43 Auto Body Shops 40 Craft Stores 40 Fabric Stores 39 Bridal Shops 39 Tobacco Shops 38 Carpet Stores 37 Appliance Stores 36 Health Food Stores 31 Kitchenware Shops 28 Pet Shops 28 Computer Stores 27 Dessert Shops 27 Florists 27 Camera Stores 26 Pawn Shops 25 Cake Shops 23 Off Track Betting Shops 23 Childrens Stores 22 Shopping Malls 22 Garden Centres 21 Department Stores 20 Fashion Accessories Stores 19 CD Stores 18 Sign Shops 18 Beer Stores 16 Motorcycle Shops 16 Sweet Shops 16 Hobby Shops 16 Tailors 14 Baby Stores 12 Bicycle Stores 12 Bathroom Supply Stores 12 Ice Cream Shops 10 Flooring Stores 10 Antique Stores 8 Asian Grocery Stores 8 Post Offices 8 Computer Software Stores 7 Bedding Stores 7 Shoe Repair Shops 7 Camping Stores 6 Auto Glass Shops 6 Fruit and Vegetable Stores 6 Farm Shops 5 Sandwich Shops 4 Balloon Stores 4 Motorcycle Repair Shops 4 Photo Shops 2 Picture Frame Shops 2 Body Piercing Shops 1 Dress Shops 1 Barber Shops 1 Chocolate Shops 1 Other Shops 1,305

Other Amenities in Chad Valley

Pubs 511 Restaurants 2,491 Banks 76 Hotels 191 Supermarkets 274 Takeaways 797 Cinemas 17 Attractions 787 Business services 466 Education 1,199 Health and beauty 2,890 Home improvement 858 Leisure 167 Property services 289

Additional Amenity Sub-categories in Chad Valley, West Midlands

← Back to all amenities in Chad Valley, West Midlands

For each listing we have opening times, address, phone number, reviews and photos

Local Information

Distances in these cards are measured from the centre of the B15 postcode district.

County or areaWest Midlands

Postcode districtB15

Telephone codeNot listed

Time zoneEurope/London (GMT/BST)

Daylight through the yearLongest day (Jun 21): 16 h 50 min4:44 am – 9:34 pmShortest day (Dec 21): 7 h 40 min8:15 am – 3:55 pm

Sun todaySunrise –Sunset –

People10,274 residentsin the Edgbaston South & University census areaMedian age 22.72,649 households55% of homes owner-occupied31% owned outright6% social rented, 39% private rentedSource: Office for National Statistics, Census 2021

Work and commuting13.5% unemployment rate41% of adults are economically active, 3,288 in work, 11% retiredMain industries: health and social work 24%, education 19%, retail and wholesale 11%Getting to work: 42% work from home, 38% go by car, 7% take public transport, 12% walk or cycle70% of those who travel work within 10 km of homeSource: Office for National Statistics, Census 2021

Education and languages41% of adults hold a degree or higher7% have no qualificationsMain language: English 84%3% cannot speak English wellSource: Office for National Statistics, Census 2021

ClimateWarmest month July: highs 21°C, lows 12°CColdest month January: highs 7°C, lows 2°C806 mm of rain a year, 21 days with 10 mm or morewettest month November37 days of air frost, 11 summer days above 25°C in a typical yearSource: Met Office HadUK-Grid 1991-2020 averages, 2 km grid (highs and lows from the 12 km grid)

Nearby landmarksCanalside Bridge 84Ahistoric site · under a milePerrott's Follyhistoric site · under a mileMoor Poollake · under a mileEdgbaston Poollake · 1.0 miWaterfront Walkwalk or trail · 1.3 miSt Vincent Street Bridgebridge · 1.0 miIcknield Port Loopwater · 1.0 miSoho Loopwater · 1.5 miSources: Ordnance Survey Open Names; Overture Maps

Parks and green spacesChamberlain Gardenspark · under a mile · 4 haHarborne Walkwaypark · under a mile · 3 haCannon Hill Parkpark · 1.5 mi · 70 haEdgbaston Golf Coursegolf course · under a mile · 58 haEdgbaston Archery and Lawn Tennis Societysports ground · under a mileEdgbaston Guinea Gardensallotments · under a mile · 5 haSource: Ordnance Survey Open Greenspace

Earthquakes122 of magnitude 2 or more within 50 miles since 197015 of magnitude 3+, 3 of magnitude 4+Largest: magnitude 5.0 on 2 Apr 199046 mi away, Bishop'S Castle, ShropsMost recent: magnitude 2.0 on 2 Jul 202549 mi away, Knucklas, PowysSource: British Geological Survey earthquake database

Flood riskRivers and sea: areas at High risk within 500 m of the centrea 1 in 30 chance of flooding in any year, or greaterAlso medium, low risk areas nearbySource: Environment Agency, Risk of Flooding from Rivers and Sea

Air qualityNO₂ 14 · PM_2.5 7.8 · PM₁₀ 12 µg/m³annual mean concentrations, 2024Within UK limits, above the WHO guideline for NO₂ and PM_2.5Source: DEFRA modelled background pollution maps 2024, 1 km grid

Broadband56% of premises can get gigabit-capable broadband78% can get superfast (30 Mbit/s or more)Every premises can get at least 10 Mbit/s (the universal service obligation)4,605 residential premises in the census areaSource: Ofcom Connected Nations, July 2025

Elevation143 m469 ft above sea levelLand within 1 km ranges from 125 to 174 mSource: Ordnance Survey, OS Terrain 50

Local servicesHospitalUhcw - The Harborne Hospitalunder a mileGP surgeryThe Westbourne Centre83 surgeries within 2 milesunder a milePharmacyRazi Meds39 pharmacies within 2 milesunder a mileDentistDental Surgeryunder a milePolice stationHarborne Police StationBirminghamunder a mileCash machineSRB Grills - Birminghamunder a mileSources: NHS Organisation Data Service; Overture Maps

SchoolsWithin 2 mi70 schools33 primary, 9 secondary, 15 independent, 8 special, 4 nursery, 1 sixth formIndependentEdgbaston High School for Girlsages 2-19, 797 pupilsunder a mileSecondaryHarborne Academyages 11-16, 627 pupilsunder a mileIndependentNorfolk House Schoolages 3-11, 118 pupilsunder a mileCollegeJoseph Chamberlain Sixth Form College2.1 miUniversityUniversity of Birmingham1.3 miSource: Department for Education, Get Information about Schools

Getting aroundAirportBirmingham Airport BHX7.9 miRailway stationFive WaysBirmingham1.0 miMetroEdgbaston Village (West Midlands Metro)Birminghamunder a mileBus stationBirmingham Coach StationDigbeth2.0 miBus stops135 within a mileCar parkDuchess Road Pay and Display Car ParkBirminghamunder a mileEV chargingbp PulseBirmingham10 charging points within a mileunder a mileSources: Department for Transport NaPTAN; OurAirports; Overture Maps

Distances in these cards are measured from the centre of the B15 postcode district.

Bakeries

Bakeries in Chad Valley

Bismillah Bakery - Birmingham B18
155 Dudley Rd, Birmingham B18, B18 7QW · 1.4 mi
Medicine Bakery - Birmingham B1
53 Wharfside St, Birmingham B1, B1 1RE · 1.4 mi
BJams Patisserie - Birmingham B18
63 Winson St, Birmingham B18, B18 4JR · 1.5 mi
Nannies Gourmet Edibles - Birmingham B2
51 Pinfold Street, Birmingham B2, B2 4AY · 1.6 mi
Sixteen - bakery - Birmingham B2
16 Piccadilly Arcade, Birmingham B2, B2 4HD · 1.7 mi
Cocomacs - Birmingham B2
68A Hill St, Birmingham B2, B2 4XJ · 1.7 mi
Khalids Kakes - Birmingham B18
Waterside View, Birmingham B18, B18 7JB · 1.7 mi
Habesha Cakes & Bakes - Birmingham B18
Unit 6, All Saints Industrial Estate, Birmingham B18, B18 7RJ · 1.7 mi
Auntie Anne's - Birmingham B2
Bullring Link, Birmingham B2, B5 4BU · 1.8 mi
Sunrise Bakery - Smethwick
Woodlands St, Smethwick, B66 3TF · 1.8 mi
The bake room - Warley B67, Oldbury
George Road Community Church, Warley B67, Oldbury, B68 9LN · 1.9 mi
The Bread Collection - Birmingham B2
No.1 Great Western Arcade, Birmingham B2, B2 5HU · 1.9 mi
Juici Patties UK - Birmingham B18
50 Icknield St, Birmingham B18, B18 5AY · 2.0 mi
Fenky Janes - Birmingham B18
Park Trading Estate, Park Rd, Birmingham B18, B18 5HB · 2.0 mi
Delish Bakery - Birmingham B12
Bradford St, Birmingham B12, B12 0AA · 2.1 mi
Emma's Pantry - Selly Oak
80 Raddlebarn Rd, Selly Oak, B29 6HJ · 2.1 mi
Bismillah Bakery - Birmingham B4
189 Corporation St, Birmingham B4, B4 6RG · 2.1 mi
Que's Cakes - Smethwick
High St, Smethwick, B66 3NT · 2.1 mi
Pack N Trade - Birmingham B19
161-163 Hospital Street, Birmingham B19, B19 3XA · 2.2 mi
Cake Shop - Birmingham B12
550 Moseley Rd, Birmingham B12, B12 9AD · 2.2 mi
Just Desserts - Birmingham B12
558 Moseley Road, Birmingham B12, B12 9AD · 2.2 mi
Tastey Bake Bakery - Warley B68
284 Hagley Rd W, Warley B68, B68 0NR · 2.2 mi
Fresh Cream Cakes - Birmingham B12
46 Highgate Pl, Birmingham B12, B12 0DD · 2.3 mi
Cake Shop Soho Road - Handsworth
189 Soho Rd, Handsworth, B21 9SU · 2.5 mi
Pastry House - Handsworth
207 Soho Road, Handsworth, B21 9SX · 2.5 mi
Crusty Cottage Bakery - Woodgate
77 Gorsy Rd, Woodgate, B32 2SJ · 2.5 mi
Rose Bakery - Birmingham B12
170 Stratford Rd, Birmingham B12, B11 1AG · 2.5 mi
Wedding Treasures - Woodgate
23 Birdlip Grove, Woodgate, B32 1ER · 2.5 mi
Cake Bake - Smethwick
3, Tollgate Shopping Centre, Brewery St, Smethwick, B67 7RA · 2.5 mi
Greggs - Handsworth
216 Soho Rd, Handsworth, B21 9LR · 2.5 mi
Cake Box - Birmingham B12
137 Ladypool Rd, Birmingham B12, B12 8LH · 2.5 mi
Cake Corner - Birmingham B12
145 Ladypool Rd, Birmingham B12, B12 8LH · 2.5 mi
Greggs - Selly Oak
144 Weoley Castle Road, Selly Oak, B29 5QL · 2.6 mi
Cake inn soho road - Handsworth
347 Soho Rd, Handsworth, B21 9SE · 2.6 mi
Bobbys Baguettes - Birmingham B12
212 Ladypool Rd, Birmingham B12, B12 8JT · 2.6 mi
Bamo Fresh Nan - Handsworth
16 A Holyhead Rd, Handsworth, B21 0LT · 2.7 mi
Gems Cakes 'n' Bakes - Stirchley
Pineapple Rd, Stirchley, B30 2TT · 2.7 mi
The Early Bird Bakery - King's Heath
28 High St, King's Heath, B14 7JT · 2.7 mi
Cake Box - King's Heath
THE PARADE, 63 High St, King's Heath, B14 7BH · 2.8 mi
The Grain Bakery - Birmingham B7
15 Proctor St, Birmingham B7, B7 4EE · 2.8 mi
Bismillah Bakery - Birmingham B11
361 Stratford Road, Birmingham B11, B11 4JY · 2.8 mi
Very Vegetarian Cakes - Handsworth
105 Holyhead Rd, Handsworth, B21 0HH · 2.8 mi
Levain and Cherry - King's Heath
High St, King's Heath, B14 7JZ · 2.8 mi
Conjurers Kitchen - King's Heath
2 Ave Rd, King's Heath, B14 7TH · 2.9 mi
Ten Four Bakehouse - Stirchley
Unit 11 Stirchley Trading Estate, Stirchley, B30 2PF · 2.9 mi
Teddylicious - Birmingham B19
16 Witton Road, Birmingham B19, B6 5NY · 2.9 mi
Rourke's - King's Heath
All Saints Youth Project, 2 Vicarage Road, King's Heath, B14 7RA · 3.0 mi
Cammyscakes - Smethwick
83 Lones Rd, Smethwick, B71 4LW · 3.0 mi
Togri Bakery - Birmingham B11
Montgomery Street Business Centre, Unit 17, 272 Montgomery St, Birmingham B11, B11 1DS · 3.1 mi
Medina Bakery - Birmingham B10
48 Golden Hillock Rd, Birmingham B10, B10 0LG · 3.2 mi
Hovis Bakeries - Handsworth, West Bromwich
Birmingham Rd, Handsworth, West Bromwich, B71 4JH · 3.3 mi
Cake Bytz - Warley B68, Oldbury
43 Crosswells Rd, Warley B68, Oldbury, B68 8HB · 3.3 mi
Sunny Biscuits - Birmingham B11
Atlas Trading Estate, Colebrook Rd Unit 3-4, Birmingham B11, B11 2NT · 3.4 mi
Birmingham - Birmingham B11
766 Stratford Road, Birmingham B11, B11 4BP · 3.5 mi
Sensational Cakes - Aston
125 Church Rd, Aston, B6 5UG · 3.5 mi
7th Heaven Cotteridge - Cotteridge
1865 Pershore Rd, Cotteridge, B30 3DJ · 3.5 mi
Weddings by Cake Hut - West Bromwich
Roebuck St, West Bromwich, B70 6RB · 3.5 mi
The Village Bakery - Oldbury
1 Langley High St, Oldbury, B69 4SN · 3.6 mi
Druckers Vienna Patisserie - Birmingham B11
940 Stratford Rd, Birmingham B11, B11 4BU · 3.7 mi
Cake Box Northfield - Northfield
754 Bristol Rd S, Northfield, B31 2NN · 3.8 mi
Red Velvet Patisserie - Saltley
Highfield Rd, Saltley, B8 3QF · 3.9 mi
Kareema Kupcakes - Birmingham B7
Unit 21 Mount St, Nechells, Birmingham B7, B7 5RD · 3.9 mi
Greggs - Birmingham B11
Stratford Road, Birmingham B11, B11 3RG · 3.9 mi
Lazzat Bakery - Birmingham B9
415 Bordesley Grn, Birmingham B9, B9 5RE · 3.9 mi
Drucker's Vienna Patisserie - Hall Green
146 Sarehole Road, Hall Green, B28 8DT · 3.9 mi
Sweet Parlour - West Bromwich
113 High St, West Bromwich, B70 6NY · 4.0 mi
Cream Patisserie - Birmingham B11
Unit 7c Lyncroft Rd, Birmingham B11, B11 3EJ · 4.1 mi
Bakes by Zainab - Cotteridge
66 St Francis Dr, Cotteridge, B30 3PS · 4.2 mi
First United Bakery Ltd - West Bromwich
Bethel Hall, Kelvin Way, West Bromwich, B70 7JW · 4.2 mi
M Firkin - Oldbury
7 Birmingham St, Oldbury, B69 4DT · 4.2 mi
Cake Shop - Oldbury
Unit 2, Fountain Business Park, Bromford Rd, Oldbury, B69 4BH · 4.3 mi
Greggs - West Bromwich
U17 New Square Shopping Centre, West Bromwich, B70 7PP · 4.4 mi
Samra Bakery - Oldbury
Percy Business Park, Rounds Green Rd Unit 84, Oldbury, B69 2RD · 4.4 mi
Tess' Treats - Blackheath, Halesowen
Acorn House, 101 Cocksheds Ln, Blackheath, Halesowen, B62 8LL · 4.4 mi

Showing 1 to 74 of 74. Back to all shops in Chad Valley

Add venues to this section

Best reviews

Top Convenience Stores in Chad Valley

Costcutter - deritend
100 cheapside, deritend, B12 0PR
2.2 miles away
Warley - Oldbury
105 Pottery Road, Oldbury, B68 9HF
2.5 miles away
Co op (25 Hollyfield Road South) - Sutton Coldfield
25 Hollyfield Road South, Sutton Coldfield, B76 1NY
8.5 miles away

Top Auto Repair Shops in Chad Valley

Autosales Suzuki Bilston - Bilston
Vulcan Road, Bilston, WV14 7JW
8.7 miles away
Bass Junkies - Wolverhampton
Phoenix Road, Wolverhampton, WV11 3PX
10.6 miles away
Studley Auto Centre - Studley
Unit 5 Victoria Works, Birmingham Road, Studley, B80 7AP
13.3 miles away
Peak Performance Alloy Wheel Refurbs - Kidderminster
27 Lisle Avenue, Kidderminster, DY11 7DF
15.1 miles away

Top Clothing Stores in Chad Valley

Clothing Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Coffee Shops in Chad Valley

Little Green Olive - Stourbridge
John Corbett Drive, Stourbridge, DY8 4JB
9 miles away
Maori Coffee Shop - Kinver, Stourbridge
35 High Street, Kinver, Stourbridge, DY7 6HF
12.4 miles away
Hatton Locks Cafe - Hatton, Warwick
Canal Road, Hatton, Warwick, CV35 7JL
16.7 miles away

Top Building Materials Stores in Chad Valley

Building Materials Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Jewellery Shops in Chad Valley

Jewellery Shops yet to be reviewed

Top Furniture Stores in Chad Valley

Furniture Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Electronics Stores in Chad Valley

Electronics Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Print Shops in Chad Valley

KopyKats Print - Droitwich Spa
130 Worcester Road, Droitwich Spa, WR9 8AN
17 miles away

Top DIY Shops in Chad Valley

Qutby's Hardware - Birmingham
33 Watford Road, Birmingham, B30 1JB
3.5 miles away
Wickes (1151 Stratford Road Hall Green) - Birmingham
1151 Stratford Road, Hall Green, Birmingham, B28 8BX
4.2 miles away
Warstock DIY - Birmingham
252 Prince of Wales Lane, Birmingham, B14 4LJ
5 miles away
Pensnett Hardware - Brierley Hill
131 High Street, Brierley Hill, DY5 4EA
8.7 miles away
Skirting Online - Birmingham
Gravelly Industrial Park Thompson Drive, Birmingham, B24 8HZ
4.7 miles away

Top Electronics Repair Shops in Chad Valley

Electronics Repair Shops yet to be reviewed

Top Butcher Shops in Chad Valley

Butcher Shops yet to be reviewed

Top Petrol Stations in Chad Valley

Petrol Stations yet to be reviewed

Top Auto Parts Stores in Chad Valley

Auto Parts Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Gift Shops in Chad Valley

Birmingham St Mary's Hospice Charity Shop (Pool Way) - Birmingham
Pool Way, Birmingham, B33 8NF
6.2 miles away
Special Times Greeting Cards & Gifts - Rednal, Birmingham
New Road, Rednal, Birmingham, B45 9JA
6.2 miles away
Laura Elizabeth Crafts - Dudley
21 Stone Street, Dudley, DY1 1NJ
7 miles away
Fair & Square - Stourbridge
26 Market Street, Stourbridge, DY8 1AG
9 miles away
Nice Thoughts - Coleshill, Birmingham
High Street, Coleshill, Birmingham, B46 3BZ
9.8 miles away

Top Bakeries in Chad Valley

Bakeries yet to be reviewed

Top Boot Stores in Chad Valley

Boot Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Tattoo Shops in Chad Valley

Tattoo Shops yet to be reviewed

Top Charity Shops in Chad Valley

Charity Shops yet to be reviewed

Top Discount Stores in Chad Valley

Discount Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Baby Clothing Stores in Chad Valley

Baby Clothing Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Book Stores in Chad Valley

Book Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Auto Body Shops in Chad Valley

Auto Body Shops yet to be reviewed

Top Craft Stores in Chad Valley

Craft Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Fabric Stores in Chad Valley

Fabric Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Bridal Shops in Chad Valley

Bridal Corner - Birmingham
2 Midland Road, Birmingham, B30 2ET
3.5 miles away
Brides of Solihull - Solihull
688 Warwick Road, Solihull, B91 3DX
7.6 miles away
web wedding store - Bobbington, Stourbridge
Unit 16b Wolverhampton Business Airport, Bobbington, Bobbington, Stourbridge, DY7 5DY
14.2 miles away

Top Tobacco Shops in Chad Valley

Tobacco Shops yet to be reviewed

Top Carpet Stores in Chad Valley

Carpet Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Appliance Stores in Chad Valley

Appliance Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Health Food Stores in Chad Valley

Health Food Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Kitchenware Shops in Chad Valley

Kitchenware Shops yet to be reviewed

Top Pet Shops in Chad Valley

Pet Shops yet to be reviewed

Top Computer Stores in Chad Valley

Computer Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Dessert Shops in Chad Valley

Dessert Shops yet to be reviewed

Top Florists in Chad Valley

Florists yet to be reviewed

Top Camera Stores in Chad Valley

Camera Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Pawn Shops in Chad Valley

Pawn Shops yet to be reviewed

Top Cake Shops in Chad Valley

Caffe Chino Cake Bakery and Patisserie - Birmingham
70 Hurst Walk, Birmingham, B5 4TD
1.7 miles away
Kiss Me Cupcakes - Birmingham
61 Moorpark Road, Birmingham, B31 4HE
4.7 miles away
Sweet Sensations - Wolverhampton
413 Bushbury Lane, Wolverhampton, WV10 8JY
13 miles away
Cookery Magic - stourport, Kidderminster
de beers garden centre, Worcester Road, stourport, Kidderminster, DY11 7SB
14.9 miles away

Top Off Track Betting Shops in Chad Valley

Off Track Betting Shops yet to be reviewed

Top Childrens Stores in Chad Valley

Childrens Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Shopping Malls in Chad Valley

Shopping Malls yet to be reviewed

Top Garden Centres in Chad Valley

Garden Centres yet to be reviewed

Top Department Stores in Chad Valley

Department Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Fashion Accessories Stores in Chad Valley

Fashion Accessories Stores yet to be reviewed

Top CD Stores in Chad Valley

CD Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Sign Shops in Chad Valley

Sign Shops yet to be reviewed

Top Beer Stores in Chad Valley

Beer Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Motorcycle Shops in Chad Valley

Motorcycle Shops yet to be reviewed

Top Sweet Shops in Chad Valley

Sweet Shops yet to be reviewed

Top Hobby Shops in Chad Valley

Hobby Hut - Redditch
100 Rectory Road, Redditch, B97 4LJ
11.9 miles away

Top Tailors in Chad Valley

Lorrayne Edwards Sewing Services - Stoke Prior, Bromsgrove
60 Cloverdale, Stoke Prior, Bromsgrove, B60 4NF
13.1 miles away
So N so's - Tamworth
9 Church St, Tamworth, B79 7DH
15.3 miles away
Michael's Menswear - Lichfield
12B Market Street, Lichfield, WS13 6LH
15.6 miles away

Top Baby Stores in Chad Valley

Baby Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Bicycle Stores in Chad Valley

Bicycle Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Bathroom Supply Stores in Chad Valley

Bathroom Supply Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Ice Cream Shops in Chad Valley

Ice Cream Shops yet to be reviewed

Top Flooring Stores in Chad Valley

Flooring Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Antique Stores in Chad Valley

Antique Stores yet to be reviewed

Top Asian Grocery Stores in Chad Valley

Asian Grocery Stores yet to be reviewed